The left tackle position was the most significant concern for the Kansas City Chiefs during the 2024 season. As the new league year approaches, discussions surrounding potential options for this crucial role are heating up. Let’s explore the possibilities available to the Chiefs to address this need.
In-House Solutions
Given the challenges faced in the 2024 season, it may seem absurd to consider that the Chiefs could find a solution internally. However, it is possible that current personnel can step up to meet the demands of the left tackle position.
D.J. Humphries
As a former tackle for the Arizona Cardinals, D.J. Humphries is the most notable in-house option. Many believe that the Chiefs didn't really get a fair chance to evaluate him in 2024. Kansas City signed him shortly after he was cleared from an ACL injury late in 2023, but unfortunately, he sustained a hamstring injury during his first game. Although he returned to the field, he was never able to secure a starting position again.
Pros: Humphries is a former Pro Bowl player and possesses the natural skills of a left tackle. The Chiefs might be able to bring him back at a contract that fits their budget. Moreover, ACL injuries generally require over a year for thorough recovery, suggesting he could perform even better in 2025.
Cons: The free agent market is competitive, meaning Kansas City would face challenges in retaining him against other interested teams. Additionally, at 31 years of age, he carries the risk associated with significant knee injuries, especially considering how they tend to impact larger athletes.
Kingsley Suamataia
During his rookie year, Suamataia found himself thrust into a starting role too soon, which may have hindered his development. Despite being a second-round draft pick brimming with potential, there are several areas where he must grow to be considered ready for starting duty in 2025.
Pros: The Chiefs have Suamataia on a rookie contract for three more years. At just 22 years old, he has the potential to become a cornerstone of the offensive line.
Cons: His performance in 2024 raised red flags, as he appeared overwhelmed and struggled significantly. There is uncertainty whether his early exposure will ultimately stifle his growth.
Bottom Line: Whether Kansas City goes with Humphries or Suamataia, the risk remains that they could find themselves without viable left tackle options halfway through the season.
Other Considerations: Wanya Morris and Ethan Driskell.
Free Agent Bargain Options
With around $4.3 million in cap space, the Chiefs might not be major players in free agency, yet there is potential to take a calculated gamble on a bargain deal that could pay off handsomely.
Jaylon Moore
A potential sleeper pick could be former San Francisco 49ers left tackle, Jaylon Moore, who presents an intriguing option.
Pros: In his last season, Moore allowed only one sack and two quarterback hits across 158 pass-blocking snaps. Notably, he achieved a PFF pass-blocking grade of 75 or greater in four of his five starts. At only 27 years old, he offers room for growth and development.
Cons: Similar to other options, Moore's experience is limited, so he still raises questions regarding his consistency.
Bottom Line: Should the Chiefs consider pursuing Moore, they would still want to draft another player and foster competition for the starting role, which doesn’t provide a concrete solution.
Exploring Trade Opportunities
Securing a left tackle is akin to acquiring a franchise quarterback; teams generally don't trade their marquee players without compelling reasons, meaning any deals will come with a steep cost.
Alaric Jackson
While it’s uncertain if the Los Angeles Rams would consider moving Jackson, they have shown willingness to entertain trades for various players, including standout wide receiver Cooper Kupp.
Pros: Jackson, just 26 years old, logged over 1,000 snaps at left tackle in the past season, permitting only three sacks and four QB hits. He has a well-rounded game and showcases sufficient agility to assist on broken plays, providing valuable support for quarterback Patrick Mahomes.
Cons: Standing at 6'7" and weighing 285 pounds, Jackson is somewhat lighter than typical for a left tackle, leading to occasional inconsistency in performance.
Bottom Line: With limited draft assets, the Chiefs must evaluate whether they’re prepared to give up necessary assets to bring Jackson into the fold.
Considering a Draft Solution
One challenge for the Chiefs is that consistent Super Bowl appearances leave them picking later in the draft. By the time their turn arrives, the elite tackle prospects are typically off the board. Nevertheless, there are a few noteworthy players in the 2025 draft worth considering.
Josh Conerly Jr.
Conerly featured prominently for the Oregon Ducks, playing over 1,600 snaps at left tackle during their standout 2024 season.
Pros: A gifted pass protector, Conerly quickly settles into his stance and adeptly counters speed rushers. His agility is remarkable for his size, allowing him to give up just two sacks throughout his two-season starting gig. Being only 21 years old adds to his allure.
Cons: Strength is a concern as he sometimes struggles with powerful defenders and bull rushes. Consistency will be key, and the Chiefs may need to trade up a bit to secure him.
Bottom Line: Conerly emerges as the top option for Kansas City this offseason. His unique athleticism and potential position him as a likely starter from Day 1, with the opportunity to evolve into a Pro Bowl caliber player.
What do you think about these options for the Chiefs? Time to discuss!