8 NFL Rookies Facing a Crucial Year: Who Will Survive the 2025 Redshirt Reckoning?

The Future of NFL Draft Picks: A Closer Look at Emerging Talent 🌟

It’s common to think that every NFL draft pick will immediately make an impact on their new team. However, many players require time to develop their skills and adjust to the pace of professional football. This isn't a negative; learning from seasoned veterans can lead to the emergence of exceptional talent in the NFL. Let’s explore some key draft picks from 2025 who would benefit from a “redshirt” rookie year. 🏈


Josh Simmons, Kansas City Chiefs

Josh Simmons stands out as a prime candidate for a transitional season, primarily due to his recovery from a ruptured patellar tendon sustained last season. The Chiefs currently have a strong offensive line featuring Jawaan Taylor and Jaylon Moore at tackle, with Trey Smith and Kingsley Suamataia at guard, and Creed Humphrey in the center.

Simmons, drafted in the first round, possesses the capability to become a starting lineman or even an All-Pro contender. Before his injury, he allowed just one quarterback pressure in 158 pass-blocking snaps. There's no rush for him to step onto the field in 2025, as the Chiefs can afford to take their time, particularly if Taylor opts out of his contract next offseason.


Ozzy Trapilo, Chicago Bears

The Chicago Bears adopted a “best player available” strategy during the draft, with second-round pick Ozzy Trapilo being a notable selection. Their current offensive line includes Braxton Jones and Darnell Wright at tackle alongside a revamped interior featuring Jonah Jackson, Drew Dalman, and Joe Thuney.

Trapilo has shown starting caliber talent at tackle, but there’s no immediate need for him to start. With Jones entering the final year of his contract as the team's left tackle, having Trapilo aboard earlier could ease the transition when it’s time to part ways with Jones next offseason. 💪


Justin Walley, Indianapolis Colts

The Colts selected Justin Walley in the third round, and his film shows promise. His footwork is quick yet composed, with respectable recovery speed and excellent anticipation. These attributes make him a solid choice moving forward.

However, his strength is a concern, as Walley weighs in at 190 pounds, which puts him in the lower percentile for his position. This limitation is evident in his tackling and hand-fighting against larger receivers. Allowing Walley a year to build strength could help him evolve into a starting-caliber player by 2026. 📈


Jalen Milroe, Seattle Seahawks

Quarterback Jalen Milroe is another player slated for a “redshirt” rookie season. This is largely due to the presence of Sam Darnold, who signed a new contract. However, Milroe has work to do regarding his consistency, particularly with accuracy.

Though his adjusted completion percentage of 70.5% in 2024 is respectable, it must rise significantly for him to compete effectively. With abundant talent, it’s essential for Milroe to develop reliability on a throw-to-throw basis before stepping into a starting role. 📚


Jalen Travis, Indianapolis Colts

Jalen Travis is yet another promising talent for the Colts. He's known for being an impressive athlete, boasting significant height, weight, and length advantages, but he still requires refinement in terms of technique.

Last season, he recorded a PFF run-blocking grade of 58.9. While displaying explosiveness, turning that potential into consistent performance will be paramount. With upcoming roster decisions regarding tackle Braden Smith, preparing Travis for the future is a prudent course of action. 🤔


Carson Vinson, Baltimore Ravens

Carson Vinson is recognized as a long-term project, given his size and athleticism. Standing over 6-foot-7, he has an extraordinary wingspan, ranking in the top tier for offensive tackles. Though he showcased agility and explosiveness, transitioning from Alabama A&M to the NFL presents significant challenges.

Vinson has managed PFF overall grades of 76.2 and 76.0 in his previous seasons, but he still needs time to acclimate to the NFL’s competition level. Patience will be key as he develops into a promising athlete. 🔄


Collin Oliver, Green Bay Packers

Collin Oliver was selected for his long-term potential, showcasing a remarkable pass-rush grade of 90.8 in 2024 before succumbing to injury. He possesses notable speed and agility, demonstrated by his impressive performance in the 40-yard dash and vertical jump.

As a versatile defender, Oliver can excel splitting time between off-ball and on-ball roles, but focusing on designated pass-rushing could enhance his effectiveness. With the right guidance, he could evolve into a formidable asset for the Packers. 🚀


Cameron Williams, Philadelphia Eagles

Cameron Williams comes with all the physical attributes you'd desire in an offensive tackle, ranking above the 70th percentile for most metrics. However, his game is marred by a lack of anticipation and overzealousness, leading to penalties—14 in 2024 alone.

A complete redshirt year could be beneficial for honing his technique. Working under skilled offensive line coach Jeff Stoutland in Philadelphia would provide the ideal environment for Williams to refine his game. 🌟


In summary, the right developmental pathways can transform the prospects listed above into crucial components for their respective teams. Building competence under the tutelage of experienced players provides a launching pad for future success in the NFL. With strategic training and patience, these talents can thrive and make significant contributions in the years to come. 📅

Scroll to Top